Table of Contents

MLB Prop Bets | Best Baseball Player Props Today

Baseball betting outcomes can be random, but there’s still another way to win big.

Getting odds on the deciding outcome can be difficult, but prop betting odds for baseball are often (-110), which means a coin toss. Plus, betting on props is a great way to support your favorite players.

But how does prop betting on baseball work? Is there a strategy behind it? What’s the best site to use for prop bets? That’s where we come in.

  • First, Mike Barner offers today’s best MLB prop bets, with tips on the best wagers to place along with the best sportsbooks for today’s best odds.
  • Then, Pat Pickens outlines the best MLB prop betting tips to use all season — including which sportsbooks you should typically use, what prop betting means, and other strategies.

MLB Best Prop Bet Today

There will be no shortage of wagering opportunities on Tuesday with a loaded schedule across baseball, which includes three doubleheaders. As we work our way through all of the prop picks to make, here are my three best MLB prop bets today.

All MLB gameday odds are current as of Tuesday, May 17, at 9 a.m. ET from Caesars Sportsbook.

  • Mike Barner MLB Prop Bets Betting Record: 18-27 (-3.51 Units)

Shane McClanahan UNDER 4.5 Hits Allowed (-130)

Tampa Bay Rays vs Detroit Tigers

WAGER: 1 Unit

McClanahan is already emerging as the ace of the Rays in just his second season. The 25-year-old southpaw is off to a fantastic start, sporting a 2.52 ERA, a 2.64 FIP, and an MLB-high 58 strikeouts through 39 1/3 innings.

The talented lefty has allowed just 26 hits in those frames, averaging fewer than four per start. He’s yielded more than four hits just once this season, and that was against a Boston Red Sox lineup with far more talent than this lowly Tigers squad.

Detroit is batting just .224 as a unit with the lowest ISO (.095) in MLB, so expect McClanahan to have another strong performance as our best MLB prop bet today.

Player Prop

-130

Shane McClanahan: UNDER 4.5 Hits Allowed vs Tigers

Caesars Sportsbook Welcome OfferGet Up To $1,100 in Bet Insurance
Caesars Sportsbook Logo

Bet $20, Payout $35


Best MLB Player Prop Bets Today

Check out the best MLB player prop bets to make with our props comparison tool, including projections to help you make the best decisions.

Click “Place Bet” to unlock the associated sportsbook’s welcome offer and place your MLB prop bets.

Learn more about prop bets and the best sportsbooks for prop betting.


MLB Prop Bet Today

Joey Gallo UNDER 0.5 RBIs (-190)

New York Yankees @ Baltimore Orioles

WAGER: 1 Unit

We hit this wager with ease yesterday, as Gallo endured another brutal night at the plate. He’s now slashing .191/.303/.362 with a 37.6% strikeout rate after going 0-for-5 with four punchouts last night.

With just seven RBIs in 32 games this year, Gallo isn’t much of a threat to drive in runs, especially since he hits in the bottom half of New York’s batting order. He’s also been MIA with runners in scoring position, batting .130/.231/.174 in those situations this year.

Player Prop

-190

Joey Gallo: UNDER 0.5 RBIs @ Orioles

Caesars Sportsbook Welcome OfferGet Up To $1,100 in Bet Insurance
Caesars Sportsbook Logo

Bet $20, Payout $31

MLB Longshot Prop Bet Today

Yordan Alvarez To Hit a Home Run (+320)

Houston Astros @ Boston Red Sox

WAGER: 0.25 Units

Alvarez has brought plenty of power to the plate this season, clubbing 11 home runs on his way to a .571 slugging percentage. This is nothing new for the young Astros star, who belted 33 home runs last year and owns a career .576 slugging percentage.

He’s in a good spot to go deep again tonight against Nathan Eovaldi, who’s allowed the most home runs in the American League this year (nine). I think he gives up another long ball in this game at Fenway Park, and I like Alvarez’s chances of being the one to hit it.

Player Prop

+320

Yordan Alvarez: To Hit HR @ Red Sox

Caesars Sportsbook Welcome OfferGet Up To $1,100 in Bet Insurance
Caesars Sportsbook Logo

Bet $20, Payout $84


How Baseball Prop Betting Works

Prop betting in baseball is where gamblers wager on other outcomes aside from who wins and loses, the run-line spread, or the total. There are player props, game props, and can be non-game-related props if there are special events.

For instance, if you are planning to watch the New York Mets vs. the Atlanta Braves and don’t trust the Mets to win with Max Scherzer on the mound but still want to cash in on him pitching you can bet his strikeout Over/Under prop. Or if there’s a player on Atlanta with good career numbers against Scherzer, you can bet on him to get a hit or drive in a run during the game.

If Scherzer’s Over/Under for strikeouts was set at 7.5, and he struck out 8, Over would be the winning bet. If you bet on Matt Olson to have a hit or an RBI against Scherzer and he achieves that, then that Over bet will hit too.

Best Baseball Prop Betting Sites

WinView Games

WinView Games

  • Place Prop Bets While Watching Live Sports

  • Play Against Real People, Not the House

  • Fast Payouts

Get up to $200 FREE

2x Your First Deposit up to $200

No code requiredGet bonus

New Customers Only, 21+. T&C’s Apply.

Caesars Sportsbook

Caesars Sportsbook

  • Intuitive App

  • Plenty of Markets & Bet Types

  • VIP Rewards System

Get up to $1,100 FREE

First Bet Insurance

GAMEDAYCZRGet bonus

New Customers Only, 21+. T&C’s Apply.

Betway Sportsbook

Betway Sportsbook

  • Easy-to-Use App

  • Quality promotions

  • Detailed Live Betting

Get Up To $1,000 FREE

Risk-Free Bet

No code requiredGet bonus

New Customers Only, 21+. T&C’s Apply.

FOX Bet

FOX Bet

  • Custom Bets

  • Cash-out Feature

  • Plenty of Fruitful Promotions

Get Up To $500 FREE

Risk-Free Bet

No code requiredGet bonus

New Customers Only, 21+. T&C’s Apply.

BetMGM Sportsbook

BetMGM Sportsbook

  • Terrific Promotions

  • User-friendly Layout

  • Live Streaming

Get Up To $1,000 FREE

Risk-Free Bet

GAMEDAYGet bonus

New Customers Only, 21+. T&C’s Apply.

Betting baseball props is easy with no shortage of legal online sportsbooks. Here are a few of our favorites:

WinView Games

WinView Games specializes in prop betting, offering an abundance of props to their bettors. On WinView, you play against other real players, not the house, where you place prop bets in real-time.

Are you watching the New York Mets and believe Francisco Lindor will have a hit in his next at-bat? At WinView you can bet on that and win big. Plus WinView is legal in more states than other online gambling sites, meaning if you’re in the U.S. you can probably win real money even if your state technically doesn’t offer legal, online sports gambling.

BetMGM Sportsbook

BetMGM is an exceptional option for prop betting baseball, with a slew of available markets and props for every MLB game each day.

The BetMGM also offers loyalty rewards to users as well as advice and a live-stream option for certain marquee games and events. Users can watch their games in real-time and get the most accurate and dependable info to make informed betting and win big.

FanDuel Sportsbook

FanDuel is another exceptional option for baseball prop betting, particularly since users can parlay multiple props in a Same-Game Parlay. FanDuel, which invented the Same-Game Parlay, has become the top sportsbook in the U.S. as a result of this prop-heavy betting option.

But wait, there’s more. FanDuel also recently released the Same-Game Parlay+, which enables bettors to combine multiple props from multiple games to win even bigger. FanDuel is the only sportsbook that offers that at the moment, and that feature should entice prospective bettors to participate in their service.

Caesars Sportsbook

Caesars is a terrific option for betting on props in all sports, but especially baseball. Caesars is well-known for its terrific app and regularly boosts odds for props or parlays for marquee games.

With Caesars Rewards, users can also accrue points and use them for dining, hotel stays at Caesars properties, as well as sports tickets, which means you can win big while also watching your online account soar.

Fubo Sportsbook

Fubo sportsbook is only available in a couple of states at the moment, as it was only founded in Fall 2021, but it is becoming a leader in prop betting, especially for baseball.

Fubo boasts a partnership with Major League Baseball and enabled bettors to sync the sportsbook to their streaming accounts, thus making live betting the game you’re watching a breeze.

BetRivers Sportsbook

BetRivers has a wide variety of prop betting options for baseball bettors and gives new and novice gamblers a helpful guide to betting as well as tips and advice so they can make the best decision possible.

The BetRivers app also provides more than 100 markets for every MLB game each day, and the sportsbook has an exceptional welcome offer where new users who make their first deposit of up to $250 will receive a 100 percent match.

DraftKings

DraftKings has a ton of betting options for every sport, especially baseball, and makes turning those props into a Same-Game Parlay into a breeze. DraftKings lets users combine many markets from the same game with the simple toggle of an icon.

The DraftKings online sportsbook is the most widely available option nationwide, meaning if you’re in a state where online betting is legal you are undoubtedly able to use their app.

How To Pick the Best MLB Prop Betting Sites

Ease of Use

It’s important to feel comfortable with the sportsbook that you choose to use. Whether it be the layout of their website or the ease to deposit and withdraw funds, it can make a difference in your overall experience.

Welcome Bonuses & Promotions

Keep an eye out for these bonuses or promotions as they could prove to be profitable. As far as welcome bonuses go, some sportsbooks will offer free wagers to new customers. With regards to promotions, they can include boosted odds to potentially make wagers more profitable for customers.

Variety of Props

A wide variety of props means more opportunities to win money. Not only does that mean offering game, team, individual, and season-long props, but offering more of them. A wider variety of props could also lead to added entertainment as you follow along with your wagers.

Odds on Props

This is very important. It’s not uncommon for multiple sportsbooks to have the same line on a prop. However, the odds can be different. For instance, if DraftKings has the odds on a Mookie Betts hits prop at -110 but BetMGM is boosting it +115, it’s worth it to put your money down at BetMGM.

What MLB Prop Bets are Available?

We already mentioned Over/Unders for strikeouts for starting pitchers as a prop betting option for baseball. Here’s a list of other standard prop betting options for baseball:

  • Over/under for Runs, hits, RBIs, total bases, stolen bases, strikeouts. Typically set at 0.5, will each hitter/batter accomplish that.
  • Anytime home run hitter. Will an individual hitter hit a home run.
  • Will the game go to extra innings?
  • Alternate totals. If the Over/Under for runs is set for 8.5, you can bet lower or higher options at longer or shorter odds.
  • Race to a certain run total. Which team will reach a certain run threshold first?
  • Which starting pitcher will have the most/least strike outs, walks, hits allowed, etc., Pitching props are widely available for starters but may not be featured if there is an opener.

Baseball Prop Betting Promotions

Prop betting promos like boosts are great enticements for users to bet. If the deGrom strikeout prop, or a Jose Altuve Over 1.5 hits in a game, is boosted to plus-money at one online sportsbook that is a good reason to choose a particular sportsbook over another.

One type of promotion is an odds boost. This is where a bettor receives more lucrative odds for a typical prop bet to hit.

For instance, some sportsbooks might produce curated prop parlays, like enabling bettors to wager on Max Scherzer and Yu Darvish to combine for more than 14.5 strikeouts in a game featuring the Mets and San Diego Padres. Or maybe one would boost the odds on Trout and Aaron Judge to each drive in a run in a game between the Los Angeles Angels and New York Yankees.

Other prop boosts could be for enhanced odds on Randy Arozarena to hit a home run for the Tampa Bay Rays in a specific game.

There are also welcome bonuses that are often offered for new members, including initial deposit matches up to a certain dollar amount.

Best Baseball Prop Bets

The best baseball prop bets are the ones you love, and the second best baseball prop bets are the ones you love that are boosted. So be sure to peruse each sportsbook app on a daily basis to try and find those boosted props in events you love.

Maybe a star pitcher like Max Scherzer’s Over/Under for strikeouts one night is 6.5, but a single sportsbook is boosting 5.5 to +100. Take advantage of that boost and the extra 10 percent profit you’ll gain. Or perhaps a solid hitter like Justin Turner getting a hit is boosted from -125 to +110 on one sportsbook, that’s one well worth taking advantage of.

Prop bets are great because they can hit even if the outcome you think will happen is completely wrong.

Baseball Prop Betting Strategy

Search for matchups you like and markets that seem attainable. Start small then build your way to the three- and four-leg prop parlays that more seasoned gamblers can put together.

If your favorite team has an unfavorable matchup, but you think one of your favorite players will do well, it benefits you to wager on a player prop. There’s no wrong way to choose a prop.

The key for prop betting is to look for statistical trends. Fortunately, many sportsbooks will offer trends and stats in their online platforms these days.

Common sense also pays off too. For instance, say the Los Angeles Dodgers are playing their first of a three-game series against the Colorado Rockies at Coors Field, and you know that home runs fly out of the ballpark in Denver. It would be wise to consider a player home-run prop for one of the Dodgers’ top power hitters — like Betts, Max Muncy, Cody Bellinger or someone else who has been recently driving the ball.

Benefits of MLB Prop Betting Online

Prop betting on baseball is so much better online. For instance, so many props are boosted online, which provides a bigger payout than those made at a physical sportsbook. Payouts are faster online too, giving users more playable funds to put toward other potential wagers.

Plus, users can shop for the best odds across a slew of sportsbooks as opposed to being confined to a single location, thus ensuring the largest possible payout.

How to Place a Baseball Prop Bet Online

Placing a prop bet is simple. Here’s a list of steps to do so.

  • Register at your preferred sportsbook. Be sure to click GET BONUS at the top of this page to ensure the max new player bonus.
  • Peruse the prop betting options for each MLB game
  • Find the one you like the best
  • Tap it to add it to your bet card
  • Insert the amount you want to wager
  • Press “Place bet”
  • Root for it to hit!

Where Can I Legally MLB Prop Bet Online?

Betting on baseball props is legal anywhere online sports betting is allowed. Here’s a list of those states:

  • Arizona
  • Colorado
  • Connecticut
  • Illinois
  • Indiana
  • Iowa
  • Louisiana
  • Michigan
  • Nevada
  • New Hampshire
  • New Jersey
  • New York
  • Pennsylvania
  • Tennessee
  • Virginia
  • Washington, D.C.
  • West Virginia
  • Wyoming

Choose More Than One Baseball Prop Betting Site

Having funds in more than one online sportsbook enables bettors to odds shop to find the best odds possible for their preferred baseball prop bet. But you can only do that if you have money in more than one online sportsbook, which is why keeping funds in multiple accounts is integral.

Choosing multiple sites to place bets on props allows you to search for a variety of different props. Also, it’s important to search for odds across multiple sites to help maximize your potential profits.

Various sites also offer different promotions daily, so being registered with multiple sportsbooks would allow you to take advantage of those opportunities. — PAT PICKENS

Caesars Sportsbook

Caesars Sportsbook

  • Intuitive App

  • Plenty of Markets & Bet Types

  • VIP Rewards System

Get up to $1,100 FREE

First Bet Insurance

GAMEDAYCZRGet bonus

New Customers Only, 21+. T&C’s Apply.

Betway Sportsbook

Betway Sportsbook

  • Easy-to-Use App

  • Quality promotions

  • Detailed Live Betting

Get Up To $1,000 FREE

Risk-Free Bet

No code requiredGet bonus

New Customers Only, 21+. T&C’s Apply.

FOX Bet

FOX Bet

  • Custom Bets

  • Cash-out Feature

  • Plenty of Fruitful Promotions

Get Up To $500 FREE

Risk-Free Bet

No code requiredGet bonus

New Customers Only, 21+. T&C’s Apply.

BetMGM Sportsbook

BetMGM Sportsbook

  • Terrific Promotions

  • User-friendly Layout

  • Live Streaming

Get Up To $1,000 FREE

Risk-Free Bet

GAMEDAYGet bonus

New Customers Only, 21+. T&C’s Apply.

WynnBET Sportsbook

WynnBET Sportsbook

  • User-friendly, Easy-to-Browse Interface

  • Comprehensive Array of Betting Options

  • Plentiful & Advantageous Promotions

Bet $50 Win $200

Bet & Win Free Bet

No code requiredGet bonus

New Customers Only, 21+. T&C’s Apply.

Related articles

Promotions

Welcome offer Caesars Sportsbook promotion

Get Up To $1,100 in Bet Insurance

5 stars
Welcome offer BetMGM Sportsbook promotion

Get Up To $1,000 Risk-Free

5 stars
Welcome offer BetRivers Sportsbook promotion

Get Up To $250 Free 1st Deposit Match

5 stars
Welcome offer Betway Sportsbook promotion

Get Up To $1,000 Risk Free Bet

5 stars

Schedule & Odds

Top Offers